In an op-ed for USA Today, McCain Institute Senior Director for Combatting Human Trafficking Kristen Abrams writes about the film “Sound of Freedom” and the dangerous human trafficking misconceptions it promotes. This week, the film was screened for lawmakers in the U.S. Capitol, highlighting false narratives and inaccurate stereotypes about child trafficking, and glorifying dangerous rescue tactics.
“Instead of buying into false narratives of child trafficking or promoting outdated responses, Congress has the unique ability to help create a safer world for all kids. That means leading a global coalition of governments that commits to sharing information and increasing funding for survivor protection, prevention and perpetrator prosecution, real solutions that the McCain Institute is focused on advancing,” Abrams writes in the op-ed. “It also means adopting new protections for children in the child welfare system, partnering with those who have lived experience (the real-life heroes of the anti-trafficking movement) in policymaking and investing in technology to detect all forms of exploitation.”
“While that kind of work won’t make for a box office hit, it will mean fewer children are victimized by human traffickers, a goal we can all get behind,” Abrams concludes.
Read the full op-ed HERE and below.
Op-Ed: ‘Sound of Freedom’ misleads audiences about the horrible reality of human trafficking
USA Today
By: Kristen Abrams
July 28, 2023
One of the most coveted screening spots for any film is in the U.S. Capitol building with some of the world’s most powerful people filling the audience. Important films like “Harriet” (the biopic about Harriet Tubman) and “Lincoln” (the film chronicling the last few months of President Abraham Lincoln’s life, including the passage of the 13th Amendment abolishing slavery) have secured this prized location.
On Tuesday, the film “Sound of Freedom” was shown in the Capitol Visitors Center as part of an event hosted by House Speaker Kevin McCarthy. “Sound of Freedom,” a new feature-length thriller starring Jim Caviezel, tells the story of a former U.S. Department of Homeland Security agent who works to rescue children from sex trafficking in Colombia. Like “Harriet” and “Lincoln,” “Sound of Freedom” has the opportunity to draw audiences in and help them better understand significant moments in time and crises in American history.
Since its release on July 4, the film has injected into many Americans’ summer-time conversations the important topic of human trafficking, and child sex trafficking in particular.
Unfortunately, what many don’t realize is that although “Sound of Freedom” is advertised as a “true story film,” that story is highly fictionalized, with even Angel Studios, the film’s distributor, acknowledging that they took “creative liberties.” In the film, Tim Ballard, the main character played by Caviezel, embarks on a mission through the Colombian jungle to rescue two siblings from a well-organized, machine gun-firing cartel.
No one should question the importance of raising awareness of human trafficking or of working creatively and diligently to keep kids safe from the horror of sexual exploitation. What all movie-goers – especially our nation’s top lawmakers – must know, however, is that the depictions of child trafficking and the rescue tactics celebrated in this film are highly sensationalized, misleading and do more harm than good.
Contrary to what is shown in this film, most child trafficking victims know and trust their traffickers. They are not kidnapped by shadowy strangers off street corners. A Baylor University study found that less than 10% of child trafficking cases involved kidnapping.
By highlighting false narratives and reinforcing inaccurate stereotypes, we condition ourselves to be on high alert for things like windowless vans, failing to notice actual signs of exploitation. In doing so, we may miss the economically and socially vulnerable young person lured into trafficking by offers of meals, gifts, shelter or simple companionship.
Moreover, while movies like this heighten our anxiety about perceived threats to children in public spaces, we may unwittingly ignore the online dangers young people face.
In addition to problematic depictions of child trafficking, it is also troubling how “Sound of Freedom” glorifies rescue missions, disregarding decades of research and experience showing that international sting operations are dangerous, sometimes illegal, often unethical, and fail to dismantle or discourage human trafficking. While rescues and raids make for an action-packed movie, they are far from the preferred response to any kind of human trafficking.
Instead of buying into false narratives of child trafficking or promoting outdated responses, Congress has the unique ability to help create a safer world for all kids. That means leading a global coalition of governments that commits to sharing information and increasing funding for survivor protection, prevention and perpetrator prosecution, real solutions that the McCain Institute is focused on advancing.
It also means adopting new protections for children in the child welfare system, partnering with those who have lived experience (the real-life heroes of the anti-trafficking movement) in policymaking and investing in technology to detect all forms of exploitation.
While that kind of work won’t make for a box office hit, it will mean fewer children are victimized by human traffickers, a goal we can all get behind.
Kristen Abrams is the senior director for Combatting Human Trafficking at the McCain Institute.